Legal News
Fresh Supreme Court of Pakistan judgments, orders, and developments checked against primary court material.
Supreme Court
Supreme Court upholds five Karachi evictions: later rent default, advance payment, court deposits and proof of material impairment. Analysis and judgment PDF.
Supreme Court
Supreme Court upholds Qaiser Ayub’s death sentence but acquits Amoon: digital attribution, shared internet accounts, knowledge and benefit of doubt. Judgment PDF.
Supreme Court
Supreme Court of India acquits Charming Rupon: identification doubts, missing teacher evidence, unfair medical cross-examination and a credible alibi. Judgment PDF.
Supreme Court
In SIP Mukhtiyar Ali Thebo, the Supreme Court of Pakistan recalled its earlier order and required a hearing before a reasoned decision on disputed Sindh Police seniority.
Supreme Court
In Ghulam Mujtaba v. Ghulam Murtaza, the Supreme Court ordered a fresh hearing after defective service and left the specific performance dispute undecided.
Supreme Court
In Salman v. The State, Jail Petition 565/2022, the Supreme Court rejected shifting the entire burden onto the husband after finding the prosecution evidence unreliable.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court granted bail in an FIA visa-document case on further inquiry, co-accused consistency and non-prohibitory offences, leaving digital evidence for trial.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that the statutory adjudication period runs afresh from remand, dismissing the tax Department’s appeal against an order made years too late.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court directed the trial court to decide limitation and maintainability independently of a pending plaint amendment, without finally deciding the time bar.
Supreme Court
A five-judge Supreme Court Bench sustained dissolution for shiqaq, rejected khula without the wives’ voluntary election and removed dower-surrender orders based solely on khula.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court upheld relief for Punjab traffic personnel permanently absorbed into their cadre, rejecting their return to the General District Police Cadre.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that a transfer note could not defeat EST Physical Education promotion to AEO under the 2014 Rules and restored promotion with back benefits.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court ordered outright confiscation of a vehicle used exclusively for smuggled goods, holding that SRO 499 barred its release on redemption fine.
Supreme Court
India’s Supreme Court upheld Anchla’s acquittal: an accepted DNA match did not prove when she was at the scene, while unreliable witnesses and investigation gaps left the chain incomplete.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court upheld consideration of a retired Railways employee for proforma promotion, rejecting a settled training objection and treating medically withheld training as no wilful default.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court of India granted bail in a POCSO case, rejected reliance on the victim family's 'morals', and considered prolonged custody and trial delay.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court of Pakistan held that WAPDA's 2018 service rules could operate prospectively but could not unsettle seniority and promotion rights already accrued under the previous regime.
Supreme Court
In CBI v Anil Dixit (2026 INSC 1064), the Supreme Court allowed inspection of voluminous seized records, with specific documents to be identified and produced at the appropriate trial stage; unavailable records could not be ordered from the CBI.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that an undertrial cannot be blamed for delay caused by jail or prosecution authorities, and that mere involvement in other cases does not by itself exclude statutory bail.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that an indirect DNA comparison with collateral relatives cannot by itself conclusively determine parentage and must be assessed with the complete oral, documentary and official record.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court directed federal departments to reassess employees individually within three months, holding that later Office Memorandums cannot operate retrospectively against time-scale benefits that had accrued under the applicable criteria.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that a mutation merely tendered by counsel was not substantive evidence and that a purchaser during pending property litigation remains bound by the eventual decree despite good faith or lack of notice.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court applied res judicata and finality to bar a renewed argument that the buyer should have sued for specific performance instead of using Section 77 of the Registration Act, because the same issue had been decided in 1989.
Supreme Court
In 2026 INSC 1054, the Supreme Court of India held that a rape conviction could not stand where the prosecutrix's materially contradictory account was rejected for the intertwined abduction charge but selectively accepted under Section 376 IPC.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court confirmed pre-arrest bail where the cheque amount materially exceeded the liability found in investigation, supporting the defence that the cheques secured ongoing business dealings rather than a fixed debt.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court granted post-arrest bail where the alleged firing role was joint and unspecified, the forensic circumstances required further inquiry, and lower courts had not determined whether a seriously ill 78-year-old accused was receiving adequate treatment in custody.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court maintained a murder conviction where related eyewitnesses were natural, consistent and promptly reported the occurrence, while medical, ballistic and circumstantial evidence corroborated their account.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted two murder convicts after finding the chance witnesses' presence unexplained, their detailed firing account unnatural, the physical recoveries inconsistent and medical evidence incapable of identifying the assailants.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted a murder convict where the same materially contradictory eyewitness account had already been disbelieved for co-accused and no independent evidence distinguished his case.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted a former deputy jail superintendent who acted on apparently genuine but forged court orders, explaining when a good-faith mistake of fact attracts sections 76 and 79 PPC.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted a murder convict after finding unexplained chance witnesses, an improbable firing account, an unmatched weapon, forensic inconsistencies, a defective site plan and an unproved motive.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted a man sentenced to life imprisonment for murder after holding that presence at the scene, relationship with the alleged assailants and a subsidiary role did not prove shared intention under section 34 PPC.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted two passengers where the alleged open retention of narcotics during a police chase was inherently improbable, but maintained the driver's conviction because control of the vehicle, flight and recovery near his feet proved conscious possession.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that a valuation ruling under section 25A of the Customs Act remains binding until revised or rescinded; Rule 107's 90-day period concerns valuation data, not the ruling's legal life.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court dismissed DHA Islamabad's four tax appeals, holding that local development functions alone do not establish the statutory attributes of a local authority for section 49(2) exemption.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court fully exonerated Nazir Ahmad and granted back pay from 1 August 2017 after accepting the core due-process and evidentiary objections advanced by Aftab Alam Yasir, Advocate Supreme Court.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court dismissed 20 Revenue appeals, holding that a genuine transaction cannot be re-characterised under section 109 merely because it produces a tax benefit; avoidance or reduction of tax must be a main purpose of the transaction.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that a five-seater motor car does not enter PCT Heading 87.02 merely because it is later stretched to carry ten or more persons; original manufacturer design, VIN data and reliable manufacturer evidence control the classification.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court granted post-arrest bail where severe hypertension and cardiac disease required specialized treatment unavailable in jail and continued detention threatened the prisoner's health and life.
Supreme Court
A four-member Supreme Court bench held that Nikahnama entries are primary but rebuttable evidence, Columns 13 to 16 must be read together, and an untransferable dower property may be replaced by its value.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court upheld a 1998 gift mutation supported by possession and evidence, holding that longstanding official revenue entries cannot be displaced by a bare allegation without a proper challenge and cogent proof.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that an unexplained delay in Talb-e-Muwathibat and failure to prove delivery of the Talb-e-Ishhad notice were fatal to a pre-emption suit under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Pre-emption Act, 1987.
Supreme Court
Pakistan's Supreme Court held that a seller who admitted a joint agreement remained bound for his distinct plot, while relief failed against the co-seller whose execution was not proved.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court upheld a murder conviction but ruled that deliberate police delay in registering an FIR may attract Section 201 PPC, departmental action and contempt proceedings.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that a witness may be summoned under Section 540 Cr.P.C. without a prior Section 161 statement, while disclosure, preparation and effective cross-examination must protect the accused.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that carrying undeclared US$40,000 through immigration to the final airport security check crossed preparation and amounted to attempted smuggling.
Supreme Court
In Altaf Hussain v Bayer Crop Science Pakistan, the Supreme Court held that C-Class cancellation of an FIR does not by itself prove malice, absence of reasonable cause, defamation or entitlement to damages.
Supreme Court
In Federation of Pakistan v Kamran Khan, the Supreme Court held that a probationer who repeats and passes a later Common Training Programme takes seniority with the successful batch, not the original batch.
Supreme Court
In Habib Ullah v State, the Supreme Court upheld a husband's conviction and explained Articles 122 and 129 QSO in a wife's domestic homicide.
Supreme Court
In Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa v. Mst. Bacha Jehan, the Supreme Court held that a service tribunal may invalidate an unproved resignation but cannot convert it into retirement merely because the employee completed pensionable service.
Supreme Court
In Noor Ahmed v. Mst. Rashida Bibi, the Supreme Court held that land permanently allotted to a displaced person under the 1958 settlement law vested absolutely in the allottee, while an unchallenged allotment could not be displaced through a time-barred civil suit by alleged collateral heirs.
Supreme Court
In Central Government v. Tariq Mansoor, the Supreme Court held that a broad authority to defend all departmental court cases ordinarily includes a civil revision arising from the same litigation, unless the appointment order or governing law provides otherwise.
Supreme Court
In Province of Punjab v. Bashir and a connected matter, the Supreme Court protected vested land rights from cancellation without notice and rejected a separate provincial petition filed 4,402 days late.
Supreme Court
Supreme Court held courts may refer deserving persons to Pakistan Bait-ul-Mal, but the form, amount and duration of aid ordinarily remain for PBM.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that Section 152 CPC cannot add statutory markup that changes the substance of a banking decree; substantive error must be challenged through appeal or review.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that a 30-year-old document receives only a discretionary presumption and cannot prove title where the transaction, land identity and official revenue record remain doubtful.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court upheld PVMA's liability for collectively fixing reduced ghee and cooking-oil prices, but cut the penalty from Rs 50 million to Rs 30 million.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court restored employees' seniority, holding that a six-year Gazette delay caused by the government could not defeat statutory regularization from 7 March 2018.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court acquitted Abdul Razzaq after finding the eyewitness account, unmarked cash, call data, recoveries and confinement evidence unsafe.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that remanded cases must proceed unless expressly stayed and ordered an eight-year-old civil suit concluded within two months.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court held that section 14A's bail bar applies to knowing illegal entry under section 14(2), not a tentative section 14(1) overstay case.
